Thread: engine swaps
View Single Post
Old 05-13-2008, 01:48 PM   #7 (permalink)
Simba
2/3 hp to the paws.
 
Simba's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: NY
Posts: 106
Quote:
Originally Posted by GTsRasta View Post
But it's not worth the cost.
That's somewhat subjective-- how much power, how one goes about it, what one considers "reliable", etc. In my experience, the 3S is built like a tank and does not cost more than a 2ZZ to make power on-- quite the opposite in fact.

Quote:
Based on the technology nowadays, the 2ZZ > 3S-GTE as far as reliable HP per dollar. The 3S-GTE needs more money poured into it that the 2zz can do for less. Here it is, best said by a Toyota guy that has worked and owned both motors:
In my experience, that simply is not the case. A 2ZZ needs a lot of help to get into the 350+ horsepower range, for example. A bone stock 3S will do that all day long and twice on sunday.

I also have fairly extensive experience with both engines, and the ~450hp 3S I have in my Celica GT-Four is considerably less annoying to deal with than the 2ZZ I have making ~350 in the Elise. The 3S is also fairly bomb proof by comparison. Toyota's design ethos changed a lot from the 90's to the 00's, for the worse in my opinion. The 2ZZ might be lighter, might have the VVT emissions band-aid and a few other bells and whistles the 3S doesn't in stock form, but it's not a better engine by any stretch of the imagination IMO.
Simba is offline   Reply With Quote