Your best bet for both color match and price is to try and find a local upholstery shop and have them do it for you. My local shop redid both my seats with read leather inserts, made a new center console with cup holder also in red leather and redid the hardtop liner in red leather, all for about $1500. The seat centers come out real easy and my interior guy said there was nothing special about the construction of them. At the same time you can have him add in some better foam and really make your ride feel nice.
A Dirge for Her the Doulby Dead in that She Died So Young