The Lotus Cars Community banner
  • Hi there! Why not register as a user to enjoy all of the benefits of the site? You may register here. When you register, please pick a username that is non-commercial. If you use a name that appears on any search engine commercially, you must pick another name, whether it applies to you or not. Commercial usernames are for supporting vendor use only. If you want to become a supporting vendor and grow your business, please follow this link. Thanks!

Very scary brake problem today... ("ice mode" victim)

22K views 64 replies 32 participants last post by  glagola1 
#1 ·
I was doing approx 60mph coming up a side turning that I have to make everyday on my commute.

Today I braked perhaps a little bit later that I normally do. It was a nice day and I was looking forward to taking the side turning "enthusiastically" such is the angle of it.

I started braking fairly hard, at least fairly hard for what I consider to be acceptable public road driving.

There is a slight undulation/bump in the road when approaching this turning. I am used to this and normally it causes no problems.

Today however it scared me ****less.

My brakes went completely crazy when I went over this bump. The ABS kicked in. And the pedal went ROCK HARD with approximately only a quarter of the pedal pressure I was originally putting in! I tried to press harder but nothing. The pedal was stiff.

I am absolutely confident there was no gravel or diesel on this bit of road. It was completely clean and clear.

Luckily I only overshot the turning by about 5 meters. Which meant I had to stop completely and select 1st gear and apply quite a big of steering lock to make the turn.

This must have looked extremely odd for the car behind and I'm grateful he wasn't right up my arse like often happens on this particular stretch of road. I was approaching the turning with some gusto and enthusiasm... only to come to complete stop. He must have thought I was an idiot.

At first I thought I had burst a brake hose or something. But I tested my brakes moments later and they were fine...

This incident is very worrying for me and to be honest I have lost a fair amount of confidence in my car now.
 
See less See more
#4 ·
Even the best ABS systems have problems while braking hard over uneven pavement... when one wheel gets "light" (i.e. hits a bump, then a void) the ABS thinks you're in lock-up and forces the system to release brake pressure. Your best response is the same as it would be if you experienced lock-up with a non-ABS brake system: release the brakes completely (and quickly) and immediately reapply...
 
#5 · (Edited)
This is very interesting as it is one of the things I think is great about my Exige. It is the only car I have ever driven where the ABS doesn't try to kill you. What year/spec are the cars that have experienced this problem? As an example where I live there is a steep downhill hairpin with a big bump in the braking area. My WRX snatches a rear wheel and the ABS fires you across the corner at unabated speed. The Exige handles it brilliantly and the ABS doesnt ruin your day as it picks up the rear wheel.

I use RS14s so the pedal pressure is really low. Does that impact the onset of "ice mode" or is the ABS re-calibrated?
 
#6 · (Edited)
I tried to press harder but nothing. The pedal was stiff.
This was your problem - it is not a Lotus specific issue it is an ABS meets something confusing issue as somebody stated above, lift, reapply, lift reapply, lift reapply , it can be done in a matter of a few seconds.... Good idea to take a high performance driving class where they let you experience threshold braking with and without ABS enabled - quite a difference ! If you really hate it on the Elise you can remove a fuse but your service engine light will always be on. I think Lotus offers some HPD full and 2 day classes at the factory in Hethel - I went to a half day class , learned a lot and had a blast and it was pretty cheap !

Also hoping you are aware of SELOC your local forum in case you have some non federal issues someday !

SELOC | Lotus Enthusiasts Club
 
#8 ·
I've already posted the same on SELOC, just thought I'd post here to get the yankee view.

It's definately not anything to do with my driving/braking style. I use the brakes smoothly, not abruptly. And I vividly remember in this particular instance I had applied the brakes smoothly.

I was slowing down with quite a bit of force. But then I hit that small undulation/bump in the road and that changed everything. The ABS started pulsing/ticking and the pedal went rock hard. Even when I had gone past this bump, like a further 10 meters I guess, the ABS was *still* going like nuts. Why is this? There was nothing left for the ABS to do be doing.

I can understand it activating perhaps for a brief split second for that bump but why did it remain active for the rest of the braking? And why did the ABS decide to remove 75% of the braking force I had originally before I hit the bump?

The only thing I can think of is that maybe when I went over the bump in the road it inadvertantly and unavoidably jolted the brake pedal at the same time.

But still, this just stinks of a software bug to me really.

I used the ABS quite a bit (playfully I might add) this winter as there quite a snowy/icey winter this year. And never did it make the pedal go rock hard. Ever. I remember playing with the ABS in one situation where I decided to press harder whilst the ABS was pulsing/ticking away. All that happened in this instance was that the pulsing got stronger and the ticking got louder... the pedal still let me push it with no problems.
 
#10 ·
Its normal. And not only happens on lotus or sports cars.

Ive had it happen to me in pick up trucks and mini vans, going over train tracks near my house.
 
#9 ·
Very easy fix.
Disconnect wheel speed sensor on right front.
Will also need to disable TC is you have that option.
This will disable ABS; ABS light will be on continously; speedo will work;
no check engine light. Reconnect the wheel speed sensor if it rains,
as ABS is helpful in the rain.

Don't pull the fuse for the ABS, because that will disable speedo.
Don't pull any other wheel speed sensor - will either cause speedo to not work
or for ABS to go into hard fault.

When you first disable, you'll likely get lock-up because ABS steps in more than you think. But after you get used to it and (re)learn to threshold brake, lap times will actually decrease because the car turns in better.

I've been running without ABS for about a year and no ice mode, whereas both my current '07 Exige and prior Exige both had "ice-mode" (hard pedal, reduced stopping,
in bumpy braking zones). I have other mods to my braking system, but I think disabling ABS is the main fix. Would appreciate testing by others. A few folks have tried and seem to agree that braking is improved. I regularly work with various instructors and all agree that brakes are improved by disabling ABS.

Other solutions might be hacking the Lotus ABS system - some work in process in this area. Another solution might be Bosch racing ABS system.
Bosch Motorsport - ABS M4 Kit
Anyone tried?

My background is in formula cars that don't have ABS.
ABS in Lotus sucks! TURN IT OFF!!!
Real racers threshold brake without any sissy ABS.

I'm thinking we may require Lotus Challenge Series w2w racers to practice with ABS on and off and then choice which ever seems safer on their car on a particular track. Ice mode seems very dangerous in racing.
 
#11 ·
Very easy fix.
Disconnect wheel speed sensor on right front.
I wanna try this for ****s & giggles. I occasionally run into ice mode and if I'm not anticipating a bumpy section in the road it can get pretty hairy. Fortunately I haven't got into any real trouble but I'd wanna try going without ABS on a strip of road I always drive on that gets bumpy and see how it feels.

Long story short, do you or does anyone have a diagram or picture on how to do this?
 
#12 ·
I've read all (or nearly all) the posts here and on other sites.
Braking anomalies aka "ice mode" seems to relate to:
sudden hard braking,
hard braking after WOT,
hard pedal,
a bump in the road,
a spin,
a turn,
going backwards,
depletion of vacuum,
a faulty vacuum valve,
bad programming,
track use,
street use,
year of the car,
sudden impending rear wheel lockup,
............
or none of the above!!-eek-
It seems to be ABS related? But I don't want to give up ABS.
To be fair I've read about "ice mode" on other mfg forums, so it's not unique to Lotus.
Short of disabling ABS, which I'm not willing to do, (feedback on vacuum fixes is inconclusive) is there a cure???TADTS
 
#15 ·
On my lotus I would get the ABS coming on prematurely when I hit small bumps in the road while braking heavily. The problem when away through a combination of machining new front upper shock mounts to give more front wheel travel and tuning the front shock bump / rebound. It also seems sensitive to front type sidewall / grip / pressure.
 
#18 ·
IMO the brakes in the Lotus are total crap. As soon as you really really slam on the brakes the abs goes crazy, and you get a slow thud-thud-thud-thud-thud sound from the abs clamping, and releasing the brake, and the car doesnt slow down at all. I think the car would stop 10x better without ABS.

I wonder if replacing the calipers with APR or something would fix the problem, or if it is really the ABS unit that causes the problem.
 
#21 ·
No it doesn't stop better without ABS, but it does flat spot tires more frequently :)

My current plan for better braking performance:

1. Tilton floor pedals (done but currently only using throttle pedal)
2. Remove ABS and re-plum lines (done)
3. Remove OEM master and servo and vacuum line and replace with Tilton series 77 for front and one for rear (not sure of bore size yet) see here
4. Add balance bar for front/rear
5. Remove my current proportioning valve and use adjuster cable for balance bar see here
6. Remove the rear caliper and replace with either EliseParts Hub or Sector 111 rear caliper kit see here
7. Buy a set of OE fronts to be used in the rear see here

About another $1350 invested beyond what I currently have ... but will give me 15" wheel options and should allow me to dial in perfect brake balance. For an 1800 lb car, I honestly don't see the need for "BIG" brake kits, OE front calipers are more than enough and they are durable (i.e. don't flex) and easier to rebuild -- I've also never had front pad wear issues nor rotor issues (using the UltraDisc setup). The BIG brake kits add weight where you don't want it.

Rob
 
#19 ·
I've had the same problem of hard brake pedal and premature (overly aggressive) ABS activation. I pulled the ABS fuse (next time I'll remove the wheel speed sensor) and flat-spotted the tires since I was accustomed to exerting a lot of brake pressure.

Glad to hear it is not unique to my car, but very disappointed to that our cars have this issue. I only realized this problem in the last few months after having the car for 5 years and autoxing for 3 years.

shock setup, brake pads, and tires can all make the problem worse.

I'm been frustrated that my Mazdaspeed 3 brakes better than my elise. Pulling the wheel speed sensor tonight and testing it out.
 
#20 ·
Try reducing your rebound damping by a fair bit to see if that helps... stiff rebound should really make the problem worse becuase it'll hang the tire.

Not denying that they probably could have engineered the system to "reset" sooner and allow for full brake pressure without such delay. It seems like the ABS stays on too conservatively long, and the traction control is too late to the game and will allow you to break the rear end completely loose if you have an LSD on throttle in a turn on smooth ground.

I've had it happen lightly once or twice on my car, but i've had it happen on my mercedes a fair bit worse so i instinctively expect that i'm not going to be able to brake very hard over bumps (not to mention it's really rough on the car anyway) so i plan my driving style to roll over bumps and then get on the brakes afterward.

Forutnately On the mercedes i have a factory ABS kill switch becuase off road ABS can be really dangerous... it's like driving with ice mode on all the time if you need to stop more quickly at all.
 
#22 · (Edited)
Old thread, I know...but I had a strangely consistent problem like the OP today and it has me stumped. Running some good hot laps on a 1.7 mile course with 11 turns, I would get a very hard pedal with greatly reduced stopping almost ever time on one turn. I "dealt with it" by releasing and reapplying braking as quickly as possible, basically a quick pump. Sounds easy enough, but I can assure you, a Vette I was chasing down probably thought I disappeared up his tail pipe one time. It was too cozy.

The braking zone was not rough. It was at the end of a 4th gear WOT straight that had me around 103 mph. The braking is initiated in a straight line here. There is another similar straight were the problem did not occur, well, maybe once.

My setup is:

15" front with 225/45
17" rear with 245/40
Hankook RS-3's
CL RS5+ pads

Any thoughts on why this would happen over and over again on one freaking corner? Still set a PB on this track config but this was really annoying.
 
#23 · (Edited)
Per lotus, the car will lock you out of applying braking force to the rears if the computer thinks they will lock up.

You can either do what you did (release and reapply at a different time when chances are the car doesn't think you'll lock the rears) or you can also just keep on it.

Does sound odd that its at the end of a straight...


Old tread, I know...but I had a strangely consistent problem like the OP today and it has me stumped. Running some good hot laps on a 1.7 mile course with 11 turns, I would get a very hard pedal with greatly reduced stopping almost ever time on one turn. I "dealt with it" by releasing and reapplying braking as quickly as possible, basically a quick pump. Sounds easy enough, but I can assure you, a Vette I was chasing down probably thought I disappeared up his tail pipe one time. It was too cozy.

The braking zone was not rough. It was at the end of a 4th gear WOT straight that had me around 103 mph. The braking is initiated in a straight line here. There is another similar straight were the problem did not occur, well, maybe once.

My setup is:

15" front with 225/45
17" rear with 245/40
Hankook RS-3's
CL RS5+ pads

Any thoughts on why this would happen over and over again on one freaking corner? Still set a PB on this track config but this was really annoying.
 
#25 ·
It happens for me on one corner pretty consistently. The braking zone is very soon after a slight bend in the road. Apply the brakes a little early, the rear drivers side wheel is a little unloaded and the car locks you out (ice mode).

Solution for me is either setup so I can brake later or reapply the brakes after ice mode occurs.
 
#26 ·
It happens for me on one corner pretty consistently. The braking zone is very soon after a slight bend in the road. Apply the brakes a little early, the rear drivers side wheel is a little unloaded and the car locks you out (ice mode).

Solution for me is either setup so I can brake later or reapply the brakes after ice mode occurs.
Probably can do something similar. It's hard sometimes to make yourself brake earlier (and less) when trying to go faster, but that's probably what I should do.

Thanks for the responses.
 
#28 ·
Unplugging the right front wheel speed sensor is easy, but does anyone know of a way to disable ABS but still keep traction control? I'd rather not remove ABS entirely, I just want to disable it on the track, and I like the adjustable TC (dialed down, but not off). TC obviously needs the wheel sensors, but since it works through the ECU (by pulling timing to reduce engine output, I think) rather than through the brakes, it seems like this should be possible. Maybe an electrical "interrupt" switch to the ABS controller? Or would that also cut the speed sensor signal to the ECU?
 
#29 ·
I may try the unplugged wheel sensor, although I do like the anti-lock brake feature most of the time. At least the brake performance would be consistent. I would probably look like the older Miatas that always go into a corner with a locked up inside front wheel.

Traction control = pretty much worthless in my opinion. Maybe on a slick street it would be OK. It is always off on the track and I don't really drive on the street in the rain.

So, is it accurate to say that "ice mode" is a safety feature that allows some braking when the ABS cannot deal with the acute loss of traction? If so, is that something that could be toggled off in the ECU by a clever tuner? Now that would be cool.... to be able to load a track tune that kills ice mode.
 
#30 ·
So, is it accurate to say that "ice mode" is a safety feature that allows some braking when the ABS cannot deal with the acute loss of traction? If so, is that something that could be toggled off in the ECU by a clever tuner? Now that would be cool.... to be able to load a track tune that kills ice mode.
"Ice mode" is anything but a safety feature … it's an unintended consequence of poorly designed and ancient ABS software that Lotus inherited when they decided to use the ABS system developed by Kelsey-Hayes (I believe) eons ago. Lotus knows of the problem but declined invest the funds needed to modify the software to remedy it when the issue was brought to their attention years ago. Their feeling then was that this issue is really a "track/racing" use issue for which their braking systems were not designed and the abs works good enough for street use.

Also, watch out for any spins on track … once traveling backwards the ABS system gets really confused and "ice mode" (for lack of a better term) will not be ameliorated by pumping the brake. Use the parking brake if you want to try and stop somewhat quickly before encountering any immovable objects ;)

The only correct fix for the issue is to get a dual master (non-abs) braking system with bias adjustor, which is what Lotus puts on their true racing models. :)
 
#31 ·
If you are experiencing the problem in a random fashion, I'd advise thinking about how you apply the brakes. If you are absolutely stomping on them as fast as you can coming into the braking zone, this could prematurely trigger 'ice mode'.
 
#39 ·
Lotus ABS system is horrible (at least in my 2007 Exige S it was) ... if you end up going backwards (say spin on a slippery road) you have no brakes, you just continue to roll backwards until you run over the kid, dog, cat, or whatever it is that might be in the direction of you're rolling.

Another joyful experience is when one wheel is off the ground during braking (say turn 6 at Sonoma raceway) your ABS system disables all braking - that isn't fun.

And finally, if you get a flat your ABS system disables all braking ... this problem put one friend into the Wall.

As I understand it, Lotus did eventually update the ABS system with the newer cars - perhaps someone else with new Lotus can chime in on ABS performance?

As for me, I removed the ABS system long ago, just too dangerous on track. I could brake later with ABS but it masked a few problems:

1. Doesn't help you identify the variants in "grip" on track surface as it tends to mask the differences on and off line.
2. The front/rear bias imbalance the car comes with out of the factory.

I've finally moved to the PilBeam setup with correctly sized masters (for my calipers) and balance bar to fine tuning front/rear.

Rob
 

Attachments

#41 ·
Davemk1,

Thanks for posting that. It was in the back of my mind while reading through the thread and then I hit your post. Still, the problem during a spin mentioned by Robains and Jack exists and I never have heard an "official" explanation of the logic involved. Anyone, please?
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top