I've been searching for the last two months and it appears the current market is supporting a price between $40k-$46k. I'm only looking at cars with Starshield, Track, Touring, LSD though so I would not pay more than $40k for the example you cited...if the dealer actually contacted you I think it supports my opinion.
I just completed a deal for an '07 Argent Red Exige S at $45k. It has one thousand miles on it, all options, plus a Focal Stereo upgrade. At smithvolvo.com there is a new '07 Exige S with the same options but in the Storm Titanium color and that one can be had for $46k.
Last edited by jkfortsmith; 07-19-2009 at 05:53 AM.