For reference, I paid ~41K for a 2007 Exige S with star shield, touring pack, and track pack. It had 6,500 miles on it.
There was a ding on the intercooler, probably from hard rev drops torquing the engine mounts, and the backup lights didn't exist. The oil smelled a little like gas, possibly from running too rich, but I never figured it out. It got totalled after a month, so no complaints, it was pristine for as long as I had it.
It's not too fishy to find a deal like that in a more rural area, especially in this economy. I snapped mine up out of Texas, same day it was listed. I think it was haunted though. It made weird noises when I was alone with it in the garage at night, and smashed into a tree after someone hit me.
Same color as that one too...
They say on a cold, dark winters night you can still hear it's supercharger if you listen close...
2009 135i - Black Sapphire Metallic/Coral red.
2007 Lotus Exige S (deceased) - Storm Titanium.
May the roar of your supercharger forever shatter the serenity of the heavens <3