I fell in love with the S1 long before the S2 existed, but I was not aware of there being any form of US legal S1 until recently when I was looking into importing a 96, I learned about the Sun speed or Sun international cars where they built them as a kit with a honda engine. If anyone has one and is considering getting rid of one please let me know. One sold on BaT back in March of last year for $33,500, and that one was Cali legal, so I feel like that is a fair starting point for pricing. Below is the link of the one from last year. I am looking into importing one still, but it would be unlikely to happen until next year, I am also talking to Sun speed about trying to do one of their kits, but am unsure if that's still an option. I will be getting an S1, it's just a matter of where it comes from.
bringatrailer.com

19-Years-Owned B18-Powered 1996 Lotus Elise 5-Speed
Bid for the chance to own a 19-Years-Owned B18-Powered 1996 Lotus Elise 5-Speed at auction with Bring a Trailer, the home of the best vintage and classic cars online. Lot #29,096.