I am wondering if I should push for a higher settlement while I have the time. When you include subtracting the deductable they have it at about 36.5k on an 06 with 16k miles. I do have GAP insurance which will cover the rest and I think it would also cover my deductable (anyone know about this, the rep on the phone for my CU just said "yes" to every question I asked and I dont think she was really paying attention lol). Anyway, I know Geico compares to other vehicles prices in the area. Within 100 miles there are only 2 06's for sale and they just happen to be low priced ones(35 - 37k). Is this even worth pursuing?