I'm a lot more inclined to believe the 5+ time.
So it looks like, yeah they liked it, but on the last paragraph it says the Porsche is a better buy due to pricing.
So why the reticence? Well, it boils down to the price. Even the rear seat-less '2+0' model is a few grand more expensive than the Porsche Cayman S, which would still be the sensible buy, despite slightly better fuel economy and emissions from the Lotus.
But that's OK. Lotus doesn't want to build as many cars as Porsche does, so you can bask in its exclusivity. And just look at it.