The Lotus Cars Community banner
  • Hi there! Why not register as a user to enjoy all of the benefits of the site? You may register here. When you register, please pick a username that is non-commercial. If you use a name that appears on any search engine commercially, you must pick another name, whether it applies to you or not. Commercial usernames are for supporting vendor use only. If you want to become a supporting vendor and grow your business, please follow this link. Thanks!

Lotus Evora - Shifting/Clutch Issue

6.9K views 27 replies 16 participants last post by  jdoc1949  
#1 · (Edited)
Cheers cheers cheers lads,

Creating this thread to document an (apparently common) shift/clutch/gear issue that the earlier models have. Opinions welcome.

-Bought Evora in TX yesterday, my cunning plan to drive back to orange county w/out paying transportation costs.
-Drove 750 miles straight (temps ranged from 85 to 65). Whoops.
-Drove into first gas station, car wouldn't physically shift into gear. Oh so naively attributed this to a fluke - willed it out of my consciousness.
-Drove into second gas station, had to coast car into parking spot. Stubborn knob wouldn't shift into any gear, it seemed decidedly comfortable remaining in neutral.
-Parked, I was unable to shift through gears. But when I turned the car off (with clutch engaged) occasionally able to shift through gears.
-Under the pale midnight moon, while sobbing quietly alone in my car in the middle of no where, I fruitlessly tried to shift through gears, engine and wrench lights eventually both turned on, to my delight.
-This morning clutch pedal is completely engaged (maybe a few inches of leeway).
-Getting it shipped back to A1 in California to diagnose.

Been sleuthing through threads and it seems all too typical this will need a $9k+ clutch replacement my dear Watson. Thought I was being cute buying a sports car with Toyota parts.

Car has 30k miles (2011). Thank god for Bitcoin but I'm not completely decided I'll keep the car so if people want to shoot me offers I'm all ears.

Will continue to document...
 
#5 ·
Could be anything from a bad master, bad slave, fluid needs flushed, all the way to a ruined pressure plate or throwout bearing.

I'd start with the hydraulics. Easy enough to get eyes on the Slave (from below) and see if it moves when you push in the clutch.
 
#7 ·
like others said it sounds like you are not even getting to the point where the clutch functions....somewhere between your foot and the clutch is probably the issue. best of luck. i had to replace my clutch master cyliner last year on my 2011 at 35,XXX miles...second owner. common problem...the rubber seals basically melting and showed up when doing a break fluid flush lol!!
 
#9 ·
-Preemptively ordered the Wilwood MC
-Remaining wildly pessimistic

The dropped clutch pedal was only the very last symptom. Can other owners confirm strong resistance when trying to shift into gears? Wrench/engine lights?

I will say it seems obvious that whatever this issue is, it's the aftermath of running the car for 750 miles in Texas nonstop.

*I know absolutely nothing about mechanical issues so I greatly appreciate all your help.
 
#10 · (Edited)
A dropped clutch pedal is fairly common when the m/c is failing or has failed. Some have had the opposite though; a stiff pedal that won't easily go to the floor. Both ended up being m/c-related.

Any time that you can't create enough pressure in the hydraulic line to move the release fork will likely result in resistance in shifting since you're not completely disengaging the clutch.

If you got a wrench and/or the MIL lights, those are likely something else. You'll want to get an OBD reader if you don't already have one.
 
#13 ·
I have an early 2010, and I know the clutch was done really recently.

I have no idea if they did the master though, and I haven't pulled the clam to find out.

After coming from the BMW world of failing rod bearings and tearing unibodies, this Lotus is refreshingly simple to deal with. I still like my BMWs, I just did a set of rod bearings yesterday, but a bad master cylinder is pretty basic by comparison.

That's to say 'Buy it, you won't regret it'.

Most people who seem to sell their Evoras are either upgrading or are the sort of people who want something other than excellent driving dynamics.
 
#15 ·
Generally manual cars will shift smoothly when the vehicle is off. No clutch pedal needed as there are no moving shafts or gears. Clutch pedal sitting on the firewall would have me thinking hydraulics. Sorry to hear but things will work out for you. Did the prior 750 miles have you smiling and playing like a kid behind the wheel?
 
#16 · (Edited)
Well it was burning through 750 miles of a straight line drafting behind semis. But the brief time I had wheeling around town was...this car is WAY underrated. If this ends up a major expense, not sure if I'll keep it, but this thread has given me hope.
 
#17 ·
Its been stated numerous times already, but most likely M/C related issue. Probably 95% of owners on here with shifting issues have been caused by cooked fluid, bad M/C seals etc.

When getting it sorted make sure the clutch line has the heat wrap. If not, have it added. Also, the maintenance schedule says fluid change every two years. I do it every year and only use quality fluid (Castrol React SRF).

Heat wrap:


Also, as agentdr8 mentioned, get a reader to sort out the code issues. They could be caused by something as simple as a $20 brake switch which has failed for numerous LT owners over the years. Low battery (causing weird electrical stuff, trip a CEL or airbag light), brake switch (wrench, T/C light, no Sport function) and M/C issues (dreaded pedal drop) are probably the most common issues discussed here.

Good luck getting it sorted!
 
#18 ·

Don't sell it. Read my post and replace the master cylinder. Then find some twisty road and all will be well.

You bought a car that you can get everything for an oil change at WalMart but a new headlight costs 3 grand. It's all part of the Lotus mystique. You will also notice after a while that when you turn onto an "S" shaped on-ramp your brain will whisper "Chicane".
 
#20 ·
Stick foot under clutch pedal. Lift with some pressure when mpedal is at top of travel. Helps it refiil. Then pump several times. It will get you home!

DO NOT WASTE TIME REPLACING WITHE STOCK POS. GRP HAS WHAT YOU NEED!!!
 
#23 ·
Forgot to update this thread!

Yup, master clutch fixed the issue. This community is insane.


On a sad note, I plan on selling the car, so if anyone is interested, let me know (35k miles, I bought for 40k).
The car is amazing, actually even better than I was hoping. I'm not happy about this but I have an investment opportunity (even though I know these cars are appreciating!) however, will be downgrading. 😢
If everything goes to plan though I'll be back.

1289206
 
#28 ·
Just bought 2010 Evora, which had a new clutch/flywheel, and bearing at 17,000 miles. Drove from Dallas to Kansas City, lost clutch (foot to floorboard) at 200 miles outside temp was 95F. Stopped for gas open "frunk" over engine let it sit for 15-20 mins. The Clutch worked okay, back on road again, started to lose the clutch again, it started to ran cooled down to 75F clutch came back. Car drives okay with 75-80 F temp. Basically fluid is boiling at these high ambients as it is next to the exhaust manifold. I'm changing to the new Motul 600, gatting some heat shield/fire wrap for the complete clutch line on underside. May cut undertray near the slave cylinder to allow more airflow around the exhaust which is very close to the clutch line. I will also look into BOE who make a cooling tray for the underside, along with their newer Master cylinder. Other than that car is great